I am always looking for new photography related accessories that might be useful for what I do. Furthermore when holding a workshop or going out with other photographers I constantly have a closer look at other equipment that I wouldn’t have bought myself to see how it works in the field.
Unfortunately every once in a while I come across a product flawed by design (sometimes deeply) and then usually the Team of phillipreeve.net has the misfortune of listening to my complaints. They suggested to make a series out of this so others might be warned about these products. This is one of these flawed products.
Benro 150mm Filterholder for Canon TS-E 17mm 4.0 L
I just recently acquired a Canon TS-E 17mm 4.0 L (great lens, there will be a review one day) and being able to use a polarizer is mandatory for me in landscape and architecture photography (yes, even on lenses this wide as I need it to eliminate reflections on foliage and windows).
Researching my options I came across this Benro holder and a dealer on ebay who had it on offer for a very good price.
Benro is pretty new in the filter(holder) business but I nevertheless decided to give it a try.
Something positive up front: the holder comes with a rich accessory kit featuring a 95mm adapter and a 95->77mm Step Up ring so you will be able to use it on most of your other lenses as well.
The holder consists of two parts, one base part that attaches to the lens cap bayonet of the lens and then the actual filter holder which is held in place by two screw knobs.
These two screw knobs are the problem of this holder. Underneath are washers that are used to clamp the holder to the base part. As I intend to use a polarizer I obviously want to be able to rotate the holder. To rotate the holder you need to loosen both screw knobs a tiny bit.
The problem is: when rotating the holder – due to friction – you will tighten (rotating anti clockwise) or loosen (rotating clockwise) these screws.
If they get a little tigther the holder simply gets stuck. If they become too loose it will also get stuck (jumps out of the groove) or even worse: your holder including filters will drop.
In this video I made you can see the holder easily gets stuck:
Most other holders use a simpler but also better mechanism, I still have the NiSi 150mm holder for the Voigtlander 10mm 5.6 here for comparison:
There is just one pull lever on one side and on the other side the holder is secured by two small hooks. You can spin it as long as you want, never get stuck, never falls off.
Is the Benro holder unusable? No, but you need to be really really careful when you rotate it and the two screw knobs make it more fiddly to use than the products of some competitors.
I am definetly not interested in trying another Benro holder before they improve their design, not even if they are much cheaper than the competition.
PS: some of you regulars may remember I am an ambassador for NiSi filters. NiSi is allowed to use my pictures for advertising and every once in a while I receive a free product sample.
How did I end up with this Benro holder when NiSi does not make one but two different holders for the TS-E 17mm 4.0 L?
I don’t need alms and I don’t enjoy asking for free stuff so I simply decided to buy this Benro holder instead of asking for a free one.
Other items that would warrant such an article
In the past I tried some more items that I would really advise you not to buy:
- Rollei City Traveler Tripods (actually: all Rollei tripods)
- Alpine Labs Spark Remote
- B+W Star Effect Filter (covered in Sunstars article now)
- Meymoon Step Up Rings
- Commlite EF -> E adapter
- Pixco Nikon-G -> Leica-M adapter (due to light leak, see adapter article)
- Guide to FE lenses for the A7 series
- Filters for digital photography
- Review: Laowa 15mm 2.0 Zero-D FE
Latest posts by BastianK (see all)
- Review: Leica 50mm 1.4 Summilux-M Asph - June 5, 2023
- Analogue Adventures – Part 20: Kodak Color Plus 200 ECN-2 processed - June 3, 2023
- Review: Viltrox FE 16mm 1.8 AF - May 30, 2023
7 thoughts on “Short-Review: Benro 150mm Filterholder for Canon TS-E 17mm 4.0 L”
I don’t get: As I intend to use a polarizer I obviously want to be able to rotate the holder.
Are you using a square polarizer?
Don’t they test their products before putting them on the market???
Thank you for this and also for the other “warnings”.
With more friction between the blue knob and the screw the unintended rotation of the knob should be gone. Can the knob be unscrewed completly?
When I send you the lens I will put the holder in the package ?
Ok, will have a look on the holder!
Guys thank you for taking a stand. Most reviews do not give bad reviews. Great to see independent and not paid reviews. Thanks again! Credibility is everything and you have it. I personnally can’t stand the likes of Steve huff who tells you every new object he touches is the best and you can t survive without it…only give negative comments on older products as the brands are not selling them anymore (and no paid work anymore)